Five Points Cafe

Nestled in the charming town of Sayville, New York, Five Points Cafe offers a delightful blend of a vibrant bar atmosphere and a satisfying grill menu. This hidden gem is perfect for anyone seeking a casual dining experience paired with a lively spirit. From its welcoming staff to the extensive menu, Five Points Cafe promises to captivate both locals and visitors alike.

Upon entering, you’ll be greeted by an inviting ambiance, ideal for enjoying everything from a casual lunch to an exciting night out. The expansive menu satisfies diverse culinary cravings, featuring a range of delicious options that ensure there’s something for everyone. Dive into their Grill selections, where generous portions reign supreme. The Steak Sandwich and Steak Burger come highly recommended, both perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor, as noted in glowing reviews from satisfied patrons like Sue Ladue, who raved about the delicious Spin Chip App and perfectly crispy French fries.

For those who prefer sipping their delights, the drink menu at Five Points Cafe will not disappoint. Indulge in handcrafted martinis like the CucumberTini or the indulgent CoconutTini, each artfully mixed to transport your taste buds to a tropical paradise. For margarita lovers, the Blood Orange Margarita is a must-try, striking a beautiful balance between sweet and tart, ensuring a refreshing twist.

The aesthetic quality of the dishes does not stop at presentation; it's evident in the flavors. Caitlin Nofi's review captures the essence of this bar and grill perfectly—consistently delicious offerings and a friendly environment crafted by the attentive staff make for a memorable outing. Even if some patrons found the experience pleasant but not exceptional, the strong drinks, yummy bar snacks, and engaging events like Music Bingo keep the vibe lively and engaging, as shared by David H and PZ MED.

Additionally, the outdoor seating area serves as a perfect refuge for pet owners or anyone looking for a breezy spot to unwind. Dee Palouse found Five Points Cafe to be her new favorite, a testament to the establishment's ability to cater to various preferences, including dog-friendly options!

In conclusion, whether you're aiming to enjoy a delightful meal or simply catch up over cocktails while playing music bingo, Five Points Cafe stands ready to deliver. Located just a short stroll from local attractions like the Sayville movie theater and train station, it’s an experience filled with flavors and good times waiting to be explored!

• Piot Grigio ~ Ballata, Veneto, Italy
• Chardonnay ~ Vintage Oaks, California
• Sauvignon Blanc ~ Prophecy, New Zealand
• Moscato ~ Pellegrino, Sicily, Italy
• Rose ~ Juliette, France

• Cabernet Sauvignon ~ Robert Hall, California
• Malbec ~ Herencia Trabajo, Mendoza, Argentina
• Pinot Noir ~ Townhouse, California

• Red Sangria
• White Sangria

• Bud Light, USA

  US$5.00
• Stella Artois, Belgium

  US$6.00
• Bluepoint Brewing Toasted Lager, USA

  US$6.00
• Guinness, Ireland

  US$6.00
• IPA

  US$8.00
• Seasonal

  US$7.00

• Michelob Ultra, USA

  US$6.00
• Heineken / Heineken Light, Holland

  US$6.00
• Corona / Corona Light, Mexico

  US$6.00
• Miller Lite

  US$6.00
• Non-Alcoholic

  US$6.00

• Downtown Mojito/ Strawberry / Coconut

  US$12.00
• Blood Orange Paloma

  US$12.00
• Cherry Grove Punch

  US$11.00
• Rose Lemonade

  US$12.00
• Whiskey Peach Tea

  US$12.00
• Limoncello Spritz

  US$12.00
• Jalapeno Mule

  US$11.00
• Downtown Lemonade

  US$12.00
• Jalapeno & Cucumber Margarita

  US$14.00
• Mango Margarita

  US$14.00

• Cucumber-Tini

  US$14.00
• Coconut-Tini

  US$14.00
• Blood Orange Tini

  US$14.00
• Watermelon Cosmo

  US$14.00

• Blood Orange Margarita

  US$11.00
• Strawberry Margarita

  US$11.00
• Coconut Margarita

  US$11.00
• Classic Margarita

  US$11.00

• Mudslide

  US$14.00
• Chocolate Colada

  US$14.00
• Strawberries & Cream

  US$14.00
• Snickers

  US$14.00